Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
https://hdl.handle.net/10419/343478 Authors:
Year of Publication:
2026
Series/Report no.:
OIES Paper: ET No. 53
Publisher:
The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, Oxford
Abstract:
This paper assesses the competitiveness of prospective ammonia import corridors into Europe, using Rotterdam as the common landing point. It moves beyond national renewable potential, plant-gate production costs and broad pathway labels by evaluating ammonia as a delivered and documented product shaped by production pathway, site selection, inland logistics, export-port choice, maritime transport, carbon intensity, project economics and EU regulatory treatment. The analysis compares grey, blue and green ammonia pathways across thirteen potential partner countries through an integrated modelling framework that combines geospatial renewable-resource screening, port and shipping-route assessment, stochastic discounted-cash-flow analysis and a literature-based feasibility screen. The regulatory review is translated into model parameters reflecting EU's Renewable Fuels of Non-Biological Origin (RFNBO) and low-carbon eligibility, Cross Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) exposure, maritime-emissions treatment and pathway-specific emissions accounting. The results show that delivered-corridor economics are more informative than production economics alone. For renewable ammonia, the top-ten production locations in each country are selected using a proxy delivered-ammonia cost to the nearest selected export port, combining levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) and straight-line plant-to-port distance. This proxy is used as a location-ranking score rather than as a final ammonia price, Rotterdam delivered cost or net present value (NPV) result. Strong renewable resources are therefore necessary but not sufficient. Low-cost production locations can lose competitiveness through long inland links, weak port readiness or long maritime routes, while near-port locations can still underperform where renewable-system costs are high. Across pathways, grey ammonia remains financially relevant in several retained gas-based countries, although it fails the modelled carbon-intensity threshold in all retained cases. Green ammonia is the only pathway that remains compliant across all thirteen countries, yet its financial performance varies substantially by renewable profile, financing conditions, storage needs, inland logistics and shipping exposure. Blue ammonia is credible only where gas-based feasibility, carbon-intensity performance, carbon capture and Storage (CCS) credibility, methane evidence and delivered economics align. At country level, Saudi Arabia, Norway, Egypt and the United Arab Emirates represent the strongest blueammonia transition cases. Australia passes the modelled blue-ammonia carbon-intensity threshold but remains weak on NPV and shipping exposure. Oman is threshold-sensitive and improves toward the boundary by 2040, while Turkey and the United States remain above the country-level blue-ammonia threshold. Chile, Morocco, Namibia, South Africa and the United Kingdom are excluded from the main grey- and blue-ammonia interpretation by the feasibility screen. However, the United States case shows why country-level screening and project-level investment assessment must be separated. In the harmonised country-level model, the United States performs weakly for Rotterdam-oriented ammonia, as renewable-optimised production locations are linked to long domestic connections and long maritime routes. However, an illustrative project-level adjustment based on the Blue Point Ammonia Complex in Louisiana materially changes the result. By shifting the gas-based case to a Gulf Coast configuration with improved OPEX, shorter plant-to-port distance and a New Orleans-Rotterdam shipping route, the US blue-ammonia NPV improves moving from eighth to first among retained blue-ammonia cases. The Blue Point project-level case also passes the EU-equivalent low-carbon threshold used in the analysis, showing that project configuration can materially change both economics and emissions performance. The paper concludes that European ammonia import policy should become more selective, not less ambitious. Bankable trade will depend on verified corridor evidence, project-level emissions data, clear allocation of CBAM and maritime responsibilities, and targeted infrastructure de-risking. A disciplined portfolio of certified green corridors, carefully verified blue transition routes and strategic diversification options can support European industrial decarbonisation while reducing exposure to carbon-accounting disputes, stranded infrastructure and supply-chain concentration.
ISBN:
978-1-78467-298-0
Document Type:
Working Paper
Appears in Collections:
Files in This Item:
File
Size
Format
Items in EconStor are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.