Abstract:
Automatic enrolment has transformed private pension saving in the UK: workplace pension participation among eligible private sector employees rose from just over 40% in 2012 to 89% in 2024. Despite this, there are concerns that current levels of pension contributions will lead to many falling short in retirement. The Second Pensions Commission's interim report (Department for Work and Pensions, 2026) argues that 15 million working-age people are undersaving for retirement based on a 'target replacement rate' measure, implying that they are expected to face significant falls in their income and standard of living at retirement. The Commission is now considering policies to increase pension saving. A key lever for policymakers to increase pension saving, in particular among private sector employees, is through increasing the minimum contribution rates under automatic enrolment policy. The effect of these policies will depend not just on how the minimum rates are amended but also the extent to which different types of employers are currently making contributions at the minimum rates, or above them. Thus, in the first part of this report we document trends in employer contributions to private pensions over time, and how patterns of saving differ between different types of employees and employers. In the second part we consider how the government could approach increasing minimum contributions (from both employees and employers). While increasing contributions improves retirement income adequacy, there are real trade-offs. Higher contributions mean lower take-home pay today, higher employer costs and particular pressures on low earners and minimum wage-heavy sectors such as accommodation and food services. Balancing these trade-offs will be a key challenge for the Second Pensions Commission's policy proposals.