Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10419/86875
Authors: 
van den Brink, Rene
Funaki, Yukihiko
van der Laan, Gerard
Year of Publication: 
2008
Series/Report no.: 
Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper 08-026/1
Abstract: 
We introduce a new solution for bankruptcy problems that satisfies weaker versions of the Exemption en Exclusion properties from the literature. Although the principles of Exclusion and Exemption are appealing, the specific conditions under which an agent receives its claim, respectively nothing, seem arbitrary and are inconsistent in the sense that there is no bankruptcy rule that satisfies both. However, weakening these conditions (by putting lower boundaries on what is considered to be a ‘small claim’), there do exist rules satisfying both principles. In this paper we consider a Weak Exemption and a Weak Exclusion property such that there is a unique bankruptcy rule that satisfies these two properties together with Consistency and Weak Proportionality (i.e. a change in the estate effects the payoffs of agents with bigger claims more than the payoffs of agents with smaller claims). This rule turns out to be some kind of reverse of the famous Talmud rule. Moreover, we show that Weak Exemption and Weak Exclusion are each others dual, and that the Reverse Talmud rule also can be characterized as the unique Self-Dual solution that satisfies Weak Proportionality and either Weak Exemption or Weak Exclusion. Finally, we generalize the Reverse Talmud rule to a class of bankruptcy rules that all satisfy some Weak Exemption and some Weak Exclusion property (that are not necessarily each others dual), which contains the famous Constrained Equal Awards and Constrained Equal Losses rules as extreme cases.
Subjects: 
Bankruptcy problem
Exemption
Exclusion
Self-Duality
Talmud rule
Reverse Talmud Rule
JEL: 
D63
Document Type: 
Working Paper

Files in This Item:
File
Size
241.27 kB





Items in EconStor are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.